Red Rovers, Red Rovers,
Bring Martians on Over
Jim Bell
Arizona State University
Shoemaker Lecture
2025 American Geophysical Union Conference
December 15, 2025
Tonight's Journey
- Five decades of robotic exploration on Mars
- Key scientific discoveries that have reshaped our understanding
- The technological revolution from Sojourner to Ingenuity
- Current missions and the road to sample return
- Eugene Shoemaker's enduring legacy in planetary science
Eugene ShoemakerThe Father We All Share
- Co-founded planetary geology as a discipline
- Proved Barringer Crater was formed by impact (1960)
- Trained Apollo astronauts in field geology
- His impact crater studies became foundational to Mars surface interpretation
"The Moon is a record of the history of the solar system."
50 Years of Red Planet Exploration
- 1976 Viking 1 & 2 — First successful Mars landings
- 1997 Mars Pathfinder & Sojourner — First rover mobility
- 2004 Spirit & Opportunity — Extended exploration, water evidence
- 2012 Curiosity — Advanced geochemistry, habitable environments
- 2021 Perseverance & Ingenuity — Sample caching, aerial flight
Why Mars Matters
- Most Earth-like planet accessible for detailed surface study
- Preserves ~4 billion year record of planetary evolution
- Key questions Mars can answer:
- Did life arise independently on another world?
- What determines planetary habitability?
- What is Earth's future as a potentially drying world?
SojournerThe Little Rover That Could
- Landed July 4, 1997 — first Mars landing in 21 years
- Sojourner rover: 10.6 kg, ~65 cm long
- Total traverse: ~100 meters over 83 sols
- Demonstrated airbag landing system
- Alpha Proton X-ray Spectrometer (APXS) — first mobile geochemistry
- Engineering proof of concept for future rovers
Spirit & OpportunityThe Marathon Runners
- Landed January 2004 at Gusev Crater & Meridiani Planum
- 90-day design life → Spirit: 6 years / Opportunity: 15 years
- Opportunity traverse: 45.16 km — a marathon distance
- Science payload:
- Panoramic Camera (Pancam)
- Mini-TES, Mössbauer Spectrometer, APXS
- Rock Abrasion Tool (RAT)
Water, Water, Everywhere(Once)
Meridiani Planum (Opportunity)
- Hematite "blueberries" — concretions formed in water
- Cross-bedded sandstones
- Sulfate-rich evaporite rocks
Gusev Crater (Spirit)
- Columbia Hills: water-altered rocks
- Silica-rich soils (>90% silica)
- Evidence of hydrothermal systems
Mars had sustained liquid water at the surface
CuriosityThe Mobile Laboratory
- Landed August 2012 in Gale Crater
- Nuclear powered (MMRTG) — no solar panel limitations
- Full analytical chemistry lab onboard:
- Sample Analysis at Mars (SAM)
- Chemistry and Mineralogy (CheMin)
- ChemCam laser-induced spectroscopy
- Mastcam imaging
- Still operating today, climbing Mount Sharp
An Ancient Habitable Lake
- Gale Crater: 154 km diameter, ~3.7 billion years old
- Evidence for long-lived freshwater lake:
- Fine-grained mudstones (Yellowknife Bay)
- Lacustrine (lake-deposited) sediments
- Circumneutral pH water
- All key requirements for life were present:
- Liquid water • Chemical building blocks (CHNOPS) • Energy sources
Reading Mars's Climate History
- Mount Sharp: 5.5 km of layered sedimentary rock
- Lower layers: clay minerals — wet environments
- Middle layers: sulfate minerals — drying conditions
- Upper layers: dust and wind deposits — modern dry Mars
Documents the transition from "warm and wet" to "cold and dry"
PerseveranceThe Sample Collector
- Landed February 2021 in Jezero Crater
- Primary mission: Collect and cache samples for Mars Sample Return
- Current status: 43+ samples collected
- Key instruments:
- Mastcam-Z (stereoscopic imaging)
- PIXL & SHERLOC (micro-scale mineralogy and organics)
- SuperCam (remote chemistry)
- MOXIE (oxygen production demonstration)
IngenuityFirst Flight on Another World
- 1.8 kg helicopter, technology demonstration
- First powered flight: April 19, 2021
- Completed 72 flights over nearly 3 years
- Total distance: ~17 kilometers
- Maximum altitude: 24 meters
- Flight duration: up to 169 seconds
Transitioned from technology demo to operational scout
Evolution of Mars Mobility
- 1997 Sojourner: 6-wheel rocker suspension, ~0.01 km/hr
- 2004 Spirit/Opportunity: Rocker-bogie, ~0.05 km/hr
- 2012 Curiosity: Scaled-up rocker-bogie, aluminum wheels
- 2021 Perseverance: Enhanced wheels, improved autonomy
- 2021 Ingenuity: First aerial mobility platform
InstrumentsFrom Hammers to Laboratories
Spectroscopy Evolution
- 1997 APXS (single-point)
- 2012 ChemCam (remote laser)
- 2021 PIXL (micro-scale XRF)
Mineralogy
- CheMin X-ray diffraction
- SHERLOC Raman spectroscopy
Sample Handling
- RAT → Drill → Sample caching
Flying on MarsEngineering the Impossible
The Challenge
- Mars pressure: ~0.6% of Earth
- Equivalent to 100,000 ft altitude
Ingenuity's Solutions
- Counter-rotating coaxial rotors
- ~2,400 RPM rotor speed
- Total mass: 1.8 kg
- Fully autonomous operation
Future: Scout for rovers, access difficult terrain, sample retrieval
A 4-Billion-Year Archive
- Impact record: Craters preserve bombardment history (Shoemaker's legacy)
- Geological record: Stratigraphy records environmental change
- Volcanic record: Shield volcanoes document interior evolution
- Atmospheric record: Isotopic ratios reveal atmospheric loss
No plate tectonics = ancient surfaces preserved
The Case for Past Habitability
- Water evidence: Minerals (clays, sulfates, hematite), deltas, channels
- Organic molecules detected by SAM in Gale Crater:
- Complex organics in mudstones
- Seasonal methane variations
- Energy sources: Chemical gradients, potential geothermal activity
- Recent findings: Jezero delta shows potential biosignature textures
Mars's Chemical Diversity
- Igneous diversity: Basalts from primitive to evolved compositions
- Aqueous minerals:
- Phyllosilicates (clays) — water alteration
- Sulfates — evaporating water
- Carbonates — CO₂-water interactions
- Silica — hydrothermal systems
- Oxidation state: Variable, indicating changing conditions
From Warm and Wet to Cold and Dry
- Early Mars (>3.5 Ga): Warmer, wetter conditions
- Valley networks, deltas, lakes
- Greenhouse mechanism debated (CO₂? H₂? SO₂?)
- Transition (3.5-3.0 Ga): Atmospheric loss
- Solar wind stripping (no global magnetic field)
- MAVEN quantifying current loss rates
- Modern Mars (<3.0 Ga): Cold, dry, thin atmosphere
What We Still Don't Know
- Duration of habitability: Brief episodes or sustained eras?
- Organic preservation: How well do biosignatures survive billions of years?
- Subsurface water: Extent of buried ice and liquid aquifers?
- Volcanic history: When did volcanism cease? (Or has it?)
- Climate mechanism: What sustained liquid water under a faint young Sun?
The Challenges of Remote Geology
- Mobility: Rovers cover ~km/year; geologists walk km/day
- Instruments: No rover matches a terrestrial laboratory
- Communication: 4-24 minute delays; no real-time control
- Power: Constrains payload mass and operational tempo
- Risk aversion: Mission rules prevent exploring dangerous terrain
This is why sample return matters
Mars Sample ReturnThe Challenge
- Multi-mission architecture:
- 1. Perseverance (active) — sample collection
- 2. Sample Retrieval Lander — collect cached samples
- 3. Mars Ascent Vehicle — launch to orbit
- 4. Earth Return Orbiter — capture and return
- Estimated cost: $8-11 billion over ~15 years
- Partnership: NASA and ESA collaboration
No mission has ever launched from another planet's surface
Why Sample Return Changes Everything
- What returned samples enable:
- Isotopic dating — absolute ages, not crater counting
- Trace organic analysis — biosignatures at parts per trillion
- Microscopy — nanometer-scale imaging for cellular structures
- Future techniques we haven't invented yet
- Current status: Architecture under review
- Perseverance: Multiple depot locations established
The Next Decade of Mars Exploration
Mobility Advances
- Mars Science Helicopter concept
- Multi-robot systems
- Enhanced autonomous navigation
Instrumentation
- Miniaturized mass spectrometers
- Life detection suites
- Deep drilling systems
Commercial partnerships may accelerate sample return
Robots and HumansBetter Together
- Robotic precursors: Site selection, hazard mapping, resource identification
- Human advantages: Intuition, adaptability, sample selection, equipment repair
- Synergy model: Robots extend human reach, humans extend robot capability
- Key resources to characterize:
- Water ice locations • Dust properties • Radiation environment
- Timeline: Human Mars missions potentially in 2030s-2040s
Beyond Wheels and Rotors
Aerial Platforms
- Fixed-wing gliders
- Balloons
- Multi-copter swarms
Surface Mobility
- Hopping robots
- Tumbling robots
- Burrowing systems
ISRU
- Propellant production
- Construction materials
- Water extraction
Mars in ContextComparative Planetology
Inner Solar System Laboratory
- Venus: Runaway greenhouse
- Earth: Habitable oasis
- Mars: Failed habitability?
Key Questions
- What determines magnetic field longevity?
- Why did atmospheres diverge?
- Is plate tectonics necessary?
"Shoemaker's vision: Planets as experiments in geological evolution"
Mars and the Search for Life
If We Find Life on Mars
- Did it arise independently?
- Or transferred from Earth? (Panspermia)
- Huge implications for cosmic prevalence
If Mars Is Sterile
- What does that tell us about habitability?
- How rare is life?
Mars informs life detection on Europa, Enceladus, Titan, and exoplanets
The Continuing Journey
- 50 years of achievement: From Viking to Perseverance's sample cache
- Eugene Shoemaker's legacy:
- Established impact cratering science
- Founded astrogeology
- Inspired generations of planetary scientists
- The future: Sample return, human exploration, fundamental answers
"Exploration is really the essence of the human spirit." — Frank Borman, Apollo 8